Industry knowledge.

We are local, family-owned, highly reviewed, and experienced since 1966. We believe a personalized experience with your insurance is better than calling a big-box company and speaking to a stranger, especially when you have a lot to lose.

Our approach to understanding your risks starts with getting to know you, listening, and developing trust and familiarity over time. And the best part is, we represent a wide range of insurance companies to help you find the right blend of price, coverage, and service you’re looking for.

Building relationships.

At Midwest Insurance Center, we genuinely care for you, your family, and our community. And we believe it’s our responsibility to educate you on your financial wellness. Insurance is much more than selling policies to us. It’s about the relationships we create, and the future opportunities and financial protection we help provide.

Midwest Insurance Center - Insurance Agency in Indiana

By the numbers

In more ways than one, insurance is a numbers game. Midwest Insurance Center has the knowledge and experience to properly protect your family & business for years to come.

Years in Business
States Served
5 Star Reviews
Team Members
Google Rating

Client Testimonials

“Our home insurance fell through 3 days before we were closing. I called and got a better policy within a few hours and was able to close on time. Will look to them for more insurance. Thank you Tracy!”

~ Jeff Blettner

“Follow up from Melissa until the plan went through was helpful. Info on differences between adult children under 25 qualifying under work insurance but not marketplace was new information that helped. The agent gave us feedback on what hospital networks and differences in coverage went with different marketplace providers. Very pleased.”

~ Jodi Flanagan

“We worked with Katie who helped us find a health insurance plan for our family. My husband is self-employed and she helped us to find a plan to fit all our health needs. Cannot say enough wonderful things about Katie. She was knowledgeable, easy to work with, and kept us in the loop with everything we needed to do. Wonderful experience.”

~ Michelle C

“Communication is key. Midwest has been great when it comes to communicating with us. Midwest Insurance came to us as a referral and I would definitely refer them to a friend. They are great!”

~ Josh Roeda

“Tim Dekker is so easy to work with we are always on the same page. Easy to get an appointment. I would definitely recommend his services.”

~ Rebecca Kasprzak

“We have used Midwest for our Insurance for many years and have always been taken care of. I think the staff is the main reason! Anyone can write an insurance policy, it is the communication with the agency to me that is key! Most recent have been Tommy Edwards/Kelsey and Katie DeSomer”

~ Kristin VanDerNoord